To rattle or not to rattle?best fish line for crappe
Question:
simply rattle.. especially at night or in stained/muddy water.best fish line for crappe I’ve often been perplexed by the obsession with some lure companies’ claims of rattles in their lures. On the one hand, they claim that their lures are life-like, some simulate a fish in distress, etc… Well, maybe I haven’t seen it all (no maybe about it) but I’ve never seen a fish or a worm that rattles, distressed or not. I would think that that it would scare more fish than it would attract. If I could think like a fish I’d be a fishing pro instead of a just a weekend angler but it seems to me that this rattle feature of some lures is more gimmick than strategy.best fish line for crappe I do have a Rat-L-Trap in my arsenal of lures. I’ve cast it at a number of outings and have yet to get the slightest nibble with it. I’ve also got some soft lures by Storm that have rattles inside them. Again – I’ve yet to land anything with it. So, what do you guys think? Is the rattle just a gimmick that hooks more fisherman than fish? Or is there true merit in it? If you’ve had success with a rattling lure, I’d be interested in hearing what kind of fish you’ve caught as well. Thanksbest fish line for crappe
Response:
I’ve often been perplexed by the obsession with some lure companies’ claims of rattles in their lures. On the one hand, they claim that their lures are life-like, some simulate a fish in distress, etc…
Rick Clunn likes to have a non-rattling crank bait tied on for when everyone is throwing rattle traps and the bass get used to them. Bass are very curious and will come to a rattle. A rattle trap would get a bass’s attention. If it were being burned through the water, you would get a reaction strike. If the fish were too pressured it may just spook the bass. best fish line for crappe I like rattles as they add an element of sound when targeting the sparse large lily pads. A floating “Minus One” is quite weedless when cast past a large pad cluster, draw the chubby lure to the pads and bump it into/through them. Then with the pad holding the minus one rattle, rattle, rattle and wait, rattle again and very often a strike will happen. Little ones will attempt to eat it but don’t set the hook! This can be a good thing. Wait it out! Even if the lure is making rings on the surface while rattling just free of the pads. More often this will encourage the larger bass to come out of hiding and grab the irresistible wounded offering while the smaller bait fish scat. Same way with a “T” rig worm, land it on the large pad, with the tail hanging off of the back of the pad giving a visible moving target, use the weight with a bead to “clack” and vibrate the pad stem down to the bottom. Then let the worm rig fall slowly off of the pad and go to botttom. On some denser weed pads run it over several of them to give the effect of a creature hop scotching the pads. I have had bullfrogs come after and swallow a four inch power craw doing this. They use their front legs to stuff it in their mouths…..amazing! On some of the rock bottom sections of my lake I will tether a three foot section of heavy chain to a rope and drag it, this is not a rattle but the sound does attract smallies. (granddad used a window ballast) If I can I sit over a rock and just vertically raise and lower the chain to clank the links, sometimes this brings in the muskies instead. — Stony — Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Response:
Rat-L-Trap is heavy…very heavy. Do they make one that suspends or floats?
Yes that is what i talk about when you stop the retrieve the Rat-L-Trap will sink and hit a snag. But recently (several years) Rat-L-Trap is offered in floater and suspending type. Try to look for them in local Walmart, Kmart (If they still around in your neck of the wood) Or Meijier or any of the sport store. A quick check at basspro or cabela Doesn’t yield anything for me. But i distinctly remember they have it. i even have two here in my tackle call Rat-l- Trap red zone . on which the box say it is a suspending type Any body else could help. Before i goto work i’ll stop by walmart and see if they still have them or not. Oh there is also another rat-l-trap product call the slapstick. It is a rattler minnow crankbait. with a twist . In water it is a floater but the weight is on its tail so the lure sit on water vertically. when retrieve it act like regular injured minnow type crank bait with different action because too much weight on tail but when you stop retrieving the lure tail swing or sink from horizontal to vertical again. Nice concept but i haven’t tried it so have do idea what it will do . Sofjan Mustopoh
Response:
Rat-L-Trap makes a floating and suspending trap.. <’((((((<
Response:
“Blaine Jones” wrote.. Three years ago when we bought the place, the seller told us that it was originally going to be a trout pond. A search through public records shows that it was built as a sediment retention pond. I’m trying to fix it up into a true fishing pond. My neighbor and I have fished bass, crappie and catfish out of other small ponds and transplanted them into mine. None have died that I can tell so far.
Nice looking pond, Blaine. Don’t let the trees and nearby bushes get out of hand. Keep them trimmed back to reduce/control the amount of leaves entering the pond. Too much decay in a small, unaerated pond can have a negative impact on water quality (oxygen content), which could reduce/eliminate food sources for your fish. I’ve been on vacation this past week so I went out in the cold weather and decided to try top-water (lots of stumps underwater and I just lost a jointed rappala lure to an underwater obstruction – the very first time I used it. Grrr…).
Keep that baby on top when the water is cold. Throw it out to the stumps and let it sit until you can’t hardly stand it any longer, then give it an easy twitch or two. Don’t fret about hanging up and losing a lure, you’re supposed to do that
Okay, so the point of all of this is that my pond water is fairly murky. I’ve been fertilizing this past year and will continue again in the spring and hopefully get it looking good.
From what I see in the pictures you may never get ‘clear’ water in there. Start from the bottom, literally, by removing as much sediment as possible. We’re undergoing a pond restoration project up here and have “strained” the silt from over 10 million gallons so far…maybe more…lemme check my math….6,000 gallons per minute x 36 hours = 12,960,000 gallons. Email me privately if you’d like details, or I can create a post on the project if anyone’s interested. For now, though, if I wanted to try a rattling lure, I’d like to get something that doesn’t dive to far and doesn’t sink because of all the stumps at the bottom of my pond.
Try a shallow diving balsa plug with a squared off lip. Pause the retrieve when you hit the stump, allowing the plug to float up and away from the stump. Have a spark plug in your back pocket in case you get snagged. Go for dark and dull colors…try chartreuse, firetiger, gold or shades of crawdad. What else would you guys recommend for this kind of situation?
Spinnerbaits. Gold blades. You can fish all levels of the water column; weave that baby left and right around the stumps, burn it past the cat tails and slow roll it along bottom. (Pssst…Blaine, cover the monitor so nobody else can see…go get yourself three Secret Weapon Spinnerbaits in 1/4 oz: Golden Shiner, Green Goddess and, since you’ve stocked crappie, a Silver Shad). If they don’t catch fish then the ones you’ve stocked are dead. Send the blades to me and I’ll reimburse you full price. — Early to Bed, Early to Rise, Fish all Day, Make up Lies. Shawn
Response:
When I used to scuba dive, you could get fish to come over by taking the dive knife and tapping the handle on a convenient rock. Bill
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – o, what do you guys think? Is the rattle just a gimmick that hooks more fisherman than fish? Or is there true merit in it? Cranks with rattles have been a top bait on every tourney trail for years and years. They have won many championships and a ton of $ for the guys that throw them. Jigs fall into the same category. Brass w/glass beads or brass tickers along with plastics do well also. History shows the rattle is no gimmick. I throw jigs with rattles about 90% of time and I catch a ton of fish on jigs and have won several tourneys on them throughout the years in all seasons and water conditions. I throw Traps and Spots in the spring and fall and they tear up the fish. Just this year I won our club’s classic on a Spot and then went back the next week to the same lake and tore them up again with the same bait. My largest bass ever came on a Trap in the spring. I fish at night a lot and will use a rattling sinker with a texas rigged plastic or a bead with a brass sinker. This has caught 100’s of fish over the years for me. I use noisy baits a lot, but I will throw quiet baits as well. In clear water or when the fish seem easily spooked, a quiet bait does better sometimes. I have blanked on noisy cranks only to start tossing a Bagley B or a Shad Rap….quiet cranks….and start catching fish. I believe the following on rattles: A rattle helps the fish find the bait in dirty water on in heavy cover. That it is one of the early tipoffs to the fish that something is coming their way due to the fact of how well sound travels. That fish are curious and will want to see what is making that noise and if happens to look a like a shad or other edible morsel, well, he’s gonna eat it most likely, especially since it is moving by so fast. That fish will hit a noisy bait better out of reaction or anger. IMO, rattles are a benefit 90% of the time and in no way hinder your success, BUT I will always try a quiet bait if the bite is slow and noisy baits are drawing less and less strikes.. Brad “You took the fall and thought of me, above all.” – Michael W. Smith
Response:
Wow…just goes to show you – you learn something new every day. I’ll continue to give rattling lures a try. On my land is a small pond (1/3 acre maybe). Three years ago when we bought the place, the seller told us that it was originally going to be a trout pond. A search through public records shows that it was built as a sediment retention pond. I’m trying to fix it up into a true fishing pond. My neighbor and I have fished bass, crappie and catfish out of other small ponds and transplanted them into mine. None have died that I can tell so far. I go out and cast a line every now and then just to see. The last fish I actually landed from there was a small bass on a jig on September 11 (unfortunately, that happens to be my birthday so that’s why I remember that that’s the last time I caught a fish). I’ve been on vacation this past week so I went out in the cold weather and decided to try top-water (lots of stumps underwater and I just lost a jointed rappala lure to an underwater obstruction – the very first time I used it. Grrr…). Anyways, I threw out a Strike King Grass Frog and after a few casts, got a bite. I reeled it in for a 4-5 seconds when he let go. Guess I didn’t do such a good job of setting the hook. Okay, so the point of all of this is that my pond water is fairly murky. I’ve been fertilizing this past year and will continue again in the spring and hopefully get it looking good. For now, though, if I wanted to try a rattling lure, I’d like to get something that doesn’t dive to far and doesn’t sink because of all the stumps at the bottom of my pond. My Rat-L-Trap is heavy…very heavy. Do they make one that suspends or floats? What else would you guys recommend for this kind of situation? If you want to take a look at my pond, I just snapped a couple of pictures about 15 minutes ago and put them here: http://www.alltel.net/~seismo/mypond.html One a dial-up it may take 1-2 minutes to load. The pics would’ve lost too much detail if I reduced their size much more (as I already reduced them 66%). Anyways, I’d be interested in what kind of lures you guys would recommend for this type of water. And yes, those are 3 pekin ducks hiding in the cat tails. Thanks! Blaien
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I realized there are already tons of glowing report on rattle crankbait. Let me add one more. My very first Bass in America was caught on Rattl Trap . It was one of the cheapest lure in Kmart (that was 1989)and produced the most Bass for me. I believe some people call it Idiot lure. any body can use it . just throw them out. crank it in. repeat again and again. vary the retrieve speed everynow and then. If you stop the retrieve, The lure will start to sink. sometimes Bass will strike at that moment. most of the time Bass strike while you retrieve and bass hook themselves. Remember not to let the rattler lure sink too much. if it sink too much the treble hook will snag at anything and everything. . While they are continuosly moving the lure will point downward. and the head of the lure will bounce off the obstacle. therefore less chance of snag. Now everybody and his brother are producing Rattler crank bait. and they look prettier every day. Last month i caught myself buying several rattler from rapalla and yozuri just because they look pretty. I still fish with the original Bill Lewis Rattler n Trap though . Hope this help. SOFJAN MUSTOPOH .
Response:
Blaine — Rattles work — but where and when can be a huge sorce of confusion to us all. (DO a search on Deja or Google of this group and read the discussion about sounds made by Spinner baits — interesting stuff) I too, have rare results with a Rat-L-Trap — but I dont throw it much…They work great along the tops of grass beds — but often I’m in thick matted weed (the hooks turn the thing into a “salad shooter”) or too open water with no cover near by. (But white bass love the things) A rattle will attract a fishes senses — the frequency of the rattle and the sound it makes under water will have a lot to do with how the bass reacts. Of the rattle attracts its sense of hearing and feeling along the lateral line — and the bait is moving quickly past — it can attract a reaction strike from the fish. In the case of a worm or jig rattle — the “clicking” is supposed to be similar to a crawfish and may intice a bass to explore what is going on. If you want to have more success with a Rat-L-trap — ask around and find a fishing buddy who likes and uses them and spend a day with them. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’ve often been perplexed by the obsession with some lure companies’ claims of rattles in their lures. On the one hand, they claim that their lures are life-like, some simulate a fish in distress, etc… Well, maybe I haven’t seen it all (no maybe about it) but I’ve never seen a fish or a worm that rattles, distressed or not. I would think that that it would scare more fish than it would attract. If I could think like a fish I’d be a fishing pro instead of a just a weekend angler but it seems to me that this rattle feature of some lures is more gimmick than strategy. I do have a Rat-L-Trap in my arsenal of lures. I’ve cast it at a number of outings and have yet to get the slightest nibble with it. I’ve also got some soft lures by Storm that have rattles inside them. Again – I’ve yet to land anything with it. So, what do you guys think? Is the rattle just a gimmick that hooks more fisherman than fish? Or is there true merit in it? If you’ve had success with a rattling lure, I’d be interested in hearing what kind of fish you’ve caught as well. Thanks! Blaine (Please remove the numbers from my address if replying by e-mail)
Response:
I realized there are already tons of glowing report on rattle crankbait. Let me add one more. My very first Bass in America was caught on Rattl Trap . It was one of the cheapest lure in Kmart (that was 1989)and produced the most Bass for me. I believe some people call it Idiot lure. any body can use it . just throw them out. crank it in. repeat again and again. vary the retrieve speed everynow and then. If you stop the retrieve, The lure will start to sink. sometimes Bass will strike at that moment. most of the time Bass strike while you retrieve and bass hook themselves. Remember not to let the rattler lure sink too much. if it sink too much the treble hook will snag at anything and everything. . While they are continuosly moving the lure will point downward. and the head of the lure will bounce off the obstacle. therefore less chance of snag. Now everybody and his brother are producing Rattler crank bait. and they look prettier every day. Last month i caught myself buying several rattler from rapalla and yozuri just because they look pretty. I still fish with the original Bill Lewis Rattler n Trap though . Hope this help. SOFJAN MUSTOPOH .
Response:
o, what do you guys think? Is the rattle just a gimmick that hooks more fisherman than fish? Or is there true merit in it?
Cranks with rattles have been a top bait on every tourney trail for years and years. They have won many championships and a ton of $ for the guys that throw them. Jigs fall into the same category. Brass w/glass beads or brass tickers along with plastics do well also. History shows the rattle is no gimmick. I throw jigs with rattles about 90% of time and I catch a ton of fish on jigs and have won several tourneys on them throughout the years in all seasons and water conditions. I throw Traps and Spots in the spring and fall and they tear up the fish. Just this year I won our club’s classic on a Spot and then went back the next week to the same lake and tore them up again with the same bait. My largest bass ever came on a Trap in the spring. I fish at night a lot and will use a rattling sinker with a texas rigged plastic or a bead with a brass sinker. This has caught 100’s of fish over the years for me. I use noisy baits a lot, but I will throw quiet baits as well. In clear water or when the fish seem easily spooked, a quiet bait does better sometimes. I have blanked on noisy cranks only to start tossing a Bagley B or a Shad Rap….quiet cranks….and start catching fish. I believe the following on rattles: A rattle helps the fish find the bait in dirty water on in heavy cover. That it is one of the early tipoffs to the fish that something is coming their way due to the fact of how well sound travels. That fish are curious and will want to see what is making that noise and if happens to look a like a shad or other edible morsel, well, he’s gonna eat it most likely, especially since it is moving by so fast. That fish will hit a noisy bait better out of reaction or anger. IMO, rattles are a benefit 90% of the time and in no way hinder your success, BUT I will always try a quiet bait if the bite is slow and noisy baits are drawing less and less strikes.. Brad “You took the fall and thought of me, above all.” – Michael W. Smith
Response:
Wow Brad, man did you just save me a bunch of writing. I add glass rattles to my soft plastics about 70% of the time. Rattle-Traps? Unbelieveable days on them, some of the best days I’ve ever had fishing. Blaine, if the water is stained to muddy you give yourself a distinct advantage by adding sound to your lure. When you first start fiahing in early spring throw the trap alot, you’ll love the feel of a bass chomping down on that sucker! Warren — http://www.fishingworld.com/MesaTackleSupply/ http://www.outdoorfrontiers.com http://warrenwolk.com/ http://tri-statebassmasters.com/
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – o, what do you guys think? Is the rattle just a gimmick that hooks more fisherman than fish? Or is there true merit in it? Cranks with rattles have been a top bait on every tourney trail for years and years. They have won many championships and a ton of $ for the guys that throw them. Jigs fall into the same category. Brass w/glass beads or brass tickers along with plastics do well also. History shows the rattle is no gimmick. I throw jigs with rattles about 90% of time and I catch a ton of fish on jigs and have won several tourneys on them throughout the years in all seasons and water conditions. I throw Traps and Spots in the spring and fall and they tear up the fish. Just this year I won our club’s classic on a Spot and then went back the next week to the same lake and tore them up again with the same bait. My largest bass ever came on a Trap in the spring. I fish at night a lot and will use a rattling sinker with a texas rigged plastic or a bead with a brass sinker. This has caught 100’s of fish over the years for me. I use noisy baits a lot, but I will throw quiet baits as well. In clear water or when the fish seem easily spooked, a quiet bait does better sometimes. I have blanked on noisy cranks only to start tossing a Bagley B or a Shad Rap….quiet cranks….and start catching fish. I believe the following on rattles: A rattle helps the fish find the bait in dirty water on in heavy cover. That it is one of the early tipoffs to the fish that something is coming their way due to the fact of how well sound travels. That fish are curious and will want to see what is making that noise and if happens to look a like a shad or other edible morsel, well, he’s gonna eat it most likely, especially since it is moving by so fast. That fish will hit a noisy bait better out of reaction or anger. IMO, rattles are a benefit 90% of the time and in no way hinder your success, BUT I will always try a quiet bait if the bite is slow and noisy baits are drawing less and less strikes.. Brad “You took the fall and thought of me, above all.” – Michael W. Smith
Response:
The rattle is great for night fishing. I’ve seen chaps make sacrifices in lures to get a louder rattle. They would use the berkley frenzy versus the rattlin rap (rapala). I hope i got the names right. For my planned night fishing next season i’m using a rattlin lure with a glow in dark finish. JMHO
Response:
I’ve often been perplexed by the obsession with some lure companies’ claims of rattles in their lures. <SNIP If you’ve had success with a rattling lure, I’d be interested in hearing what kind of fish you’ve caught as well. Thanks! Blaine
Blaine, I’ve had lots of success with rattling lures in the past fishing for Largemouth Bass. Mainly used in stained to muddy water, rapala rattlin raps have caught numerous fish for me in a variety of environments. My personal favorite is around rip-rap, but have also caught them from flats and occasionally around more wood like cover. Occasionally, fish around weedbeds find them attractive, although that has been more of an exception then a rule for me personally. Keep throwing them, especially when the water gets a little off color. You’ll find them catching fish before long… Good luck… — Andrew Kidd http://www.rofb.org – Official ROFB Newsgroup Site http://www.amiasoft.com – Home of SiteAid HTML Editor
Response:
I’ve often been perplexed by the obsession with some lure companies’ claims of rattles in their lures. On the one hand, they claim that their lures are life-like, some simulate a fish in distress, etc… Well, maybe I haven’t seen it all (no maybe about it) but I’ve never seen a fish or a worm that rattles, distressed or not. I would think that that it would scare more fish than it would attract. If I could think like a fish I’d be a fishing pro instead of a just a weekend angler but it seems to me that this rattle feature of some lures is more gimmick than strategy. I do have a Rat-L-Trap in my arsenal of lures. I’ve cast it at a number of outings and have yet to get the slightest nibble with it. I’ve also got some soft lures by Storm that have rattles inside them. Again – I’ve yet to land anything with it. So, what do you guys think? Is the rattle just a gimmick that hooks more fisherman than fish? Or is there true merit in it? If you’ve had success with a rattling lure, I’d be interested in hearing what kind of fish you’ve caught as well. Thanks! Blaine (Please remove the numbers from my address if replying by e-mail)
Categories: